APPENDICES

TO THE

DIVERSITY REPORT

Appendix A

Glossary

For the purposes of discussing a proposed diversity requirement, the following imprecise definitions may be used:

culture, definition 1: "Cultures are sets of patterned behavior learned by humans as members of particular societies." (Kehoe 1998:2). The key concept in is that culture is learned. This definition permits the assumption that each society or group has a different culture.

culture, definition 2: "The acquired knowledge that people use to interpret experience and generate social behavior" (Spradley 1979:5). This definition, too, emphasizes that culture is learned (acquired), but it does not imply a one-to-one relationship between a society or group on the one hand and culture on the other. The same person or the same group may draw on more than one culture; we are all multicultural in this sense (Goodenough 1976).

ethnicity: A social construct (see "race" below). "While diverse definitions exist, ethnicity may be defined as the identification with population groups characterized by common ancestry, language and custom." American Anthropological Association http://new.aaanet.org/gvt/ombdraft.htm

race: "Anthropologically speaking, the concept of race is a relatively recent one. Historically, the term ‘race’ was ascribed to groups of individuals who were categorized as biologically distinct. Rather than developing as a scientific concept, the current notion of ‘race’ in the United States grew out of a European folk taxonomy or classification system sometime after Columbus sailed to the Americas." American Anthropological Association http://new.aaanet.org/gvt/ombdraft.htm

"Race and ethnicity both represent social or cultural constructs for categorizing people based on perceived differences in biology (physical appearance) and behavior. Although popular connotations of race tend to be associated with biology and those of ethnicity with culture, the two concepts are not clearly distinct from one another." http://new.aaanet.org/gvt/ombdraft.htm

For example, "White" is a socially constructed label whose meaning has changed over time. In earlier eras, the Irish, Slavs, and southern Europeans were considered distinct (non-white) races. At the moment in the United States, not everyone agrees whether the label applies to people of Middle Eastern, South Asian, Latin Americans, or Jewish descent. "Black" is a socially constructed label; at the moment in the United States it usually refers to people with any known sub-Saharan African ancestry.

Goodenough, W. H. (1976). Multi-culturalism as the normal human experience. Anthropology and Education Newsletter 7(4), 4-7.

Kehoe, Alice Beck. (1998). Humans: an introduction to four-field anthropology . New York : Routledge.

Spradley, J. P. (1979). The ethnographic interview. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston.

 

Appendix B

Goals for the Undergraduate Experience and

Graduating Student Survey 2000 

 

 

 

Satisfaction with Campus Services 2000

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Appendix C

Examples of Multicultural Course Requirements

 

Collected by CASL’s ad hoc Committee on

Multicultural Commonalities and Differences in 1999

 

 

Examples of Multicultural Course Requirements


UM-Ann Arbor (LS&A): 'tRace & Ethnicity requirement" (I course)

Courses are approved by a term-by-term basis. Required content: the melning
of race, ethnicity, and racism; racial and ethnic intolerance and resulting inequality as it occurs in the United States Qr-elsewhere; comparisons of discrimination based on race, ethnicity, religion, social class, Qr gender. Required focus: subs!.antial, though not necessarily exclusive, attention to the required content [in ways that are] consistent with disciplines or fields of study. ...

UM-Flint: General Education Requirement under II Area Options."
Area Options (4 categories): Students ~~Iect two are~~ and take three courses from each selected area. Areas:
1) Analytical Reasoning ( e.g.. AF A Africana Theories ofKnowledge; Phill 03 Principles of Analytical Reasoning; Phil202 Logic; Chem 160 Principles of Chem; Phy243 Introduction to Physics; Mathl16 Mathematical Inquiry);
2) Cultural Studies
"Nature and types of human culture"--13 Anthro. Soc. PolSci. Geog courses;
"Foreign cultures"--30 AFA, Anthro. Soc. Eng. French. Hist courses both Western and non- Western;
II American Cultures"--28 AF A, Anthro. Eng. Hist. WS. PolSci courses
3) Foreign Language,'
4) Values Inquiry
"Courses that present and critically examine different theories and types of reasoning involving diverse values in such areas as ethics politics, religion. art. and literature"--19 AF A, Eng. Hist. Phil. PolSci. Soc courses~ and.
"Courses involving rigorous thinking about value-Iaden issues"--28 AF A, Eng. Phil. PolSci. Psych. Soc. SocWk courses which cover evolution. women's literature, feminist theory. law. aging. race and ethnicity. civil liberties. psychological adjustment. the family
4) Foundations of Western Civilization
23 courses "concerned with the history of western civilization. its philosophic traditions, its culture. and its political thought" and
17 courses "concerned with the western literary tradition through 19th century. II

UW-LaCrosse: General Education requirement--Liberal Studies. 2 Area:

1:Minority Cultures or Multiracial Women's Studies (Select 1 of 14 courses):
e.g., English 207 Multicultural Literature in the U.S.; English 210 Literature of Black America; History 299 History of Ethnic America; Soc 225 Racial & Ethnic
Minorities; Econ 336 Women in the U.S. Economy; PolSci 205 Women and Politics ..

2)International and Multicultural Studies: Becoming World Citizens (Select 2 of 10
courses). REQUIRED: Hist 151 World History to 1500. Electives (e.g.,): Econ120 Global Macroeconomics; Eng 128 International Studies in Literature; Geog200 Conservation of Global Environments; Phil230 Multicultural Philosophy; PoISci234 Comparative Political Systems.
~

Eastern Michigan University: General Education requirements
Area III: Social Science--student must select 1 of 22 courses in "cros~cultural.QJ. internationaLstudies" (e.g., Anthro233 People and Cultures ofMexico~ Econ321 Minority Workers in the Labor Market~ Anthro355 Anthro ofWomen~ Hist315 History of Black Americans~ Hist348 20th Century Africa~ Soc344 Sociology of Gender~ Hist375 Modern India)

Area IV: Arts and Humanities--Students select 1 C9UfSeS from 4 categories, one of which is "cross-cultural or international studies" (3 courses): F1AN2lS Cultures of Mexican-Americans and Cubans in the U.S.~ LITR204 Native American Literature~ LITR260 African American Literature. Also, there are elective courses which fulfill this requirement under Theatre Arts, (e.g., African American Theatre), and Philosophy (Phil of Women)


Oakland University: General Education requirement--"§!!!!!jc~iveJsi.tY geQuiremem"
Students must select 1 course from any of 5 academic units:
College of Arts & Sciences (29 courses covering African-American, Native American, Mexican and Mexican-American history or culture; U.S. race and ethnicity)
School of Business ( 4 courses covering consumer behavior, economics of human resources, management of human resources, principles of microeconomics)
School of Education and Human Services ( 5 courses covering social studies in elementary school, cultural diversity in the workplace, teaching of reading courses).
School ofHealth Sciences (I course--"Health Care Dimensions")
School of Nursing (I course--"Professional Nursing in the Community")

Central Michigan University: General requirement under "Integrative and Area Studies".
Students must select 1 course from eJl.9l1 of three areas (total of3 courses):

Integrative and Interdisciplinary Studies (25 courses in Antro, Econ, Hist, Humanities,
PolSci, Psych, Soc, WS such as "Dress and Culture," "Primates," "Death and Dying," "Women in the Economy," "Socialism, Fascism, and Liberalism," "Current American Indian Issues," "Environmental Geography."
Studies in Global Cultures ( 45 courses in Ant}u-o, Econ, Foreign Languages, Hist, Phil, PolSci, Religion, Soc. Courses include: "Cultures of. ..Africa/Latin America, South Pacific; " foreign languages (French, German, Japanese, Ojibwe, Spanish); "Economic Development on the Pacific Rim~ " "Chinese Societies; " "Religious Traditions
of. ..China/Japan/lndia; " "Islam; " "The Buddhist Tradition. "
Studies in Racism and Cultural Diversitv in the United States ( 18 courses in Anthro, Eng, Hist, Journalism, Phil, PolSci, Religion, Soc, WS. Courses include: history, culture or literature of Native Americans, African-Arnericans, Hispanic Americans; racism~ discrimination; politics and justice (e.g., Civil Rights movement); religion and race
("From Spirituals to Gospel").

Studies in Racism and Cultural Diversity in the United States ( 18 courses in Anthro, Eng, Hist, Journalism, Phil, PolSci, Religion, Soc, WS, Courses include: history, culture or literature of Native Americans, African-Americans, Hispanic Americans; racism; discrimination; politics and justice (e,g" Civil Rights movement); religion and race
("From Spirituals to Gospel").

 

Appendix D

UMD Alumni Survey 1996-2000

Sample = 20% of graduates 1986-1995 (N = 6,390, Respondents = 1,624, or 25%)

Goals sorted by importance to alumni

importance

impact

gap

Recognizing and using effective verbal communication skills

3.77

3.06

0.71

Defining and solving problems

3.71

3.22

0.49

Recognizing and using effective written communication skills

3.71

3.25

0.46

Living my personal and professional life according to my own standard

3.63

2.50

1.13

Working cooperatively in groups; working as a team member

3.58

3.06

0.52

Thinking objectively about beliefs, attitudes, and values

3.56

2.90

0.66

Developing and using effective leadership skills

3.56

2.61

0.95

Developing original ideas and/or products

3.53

2.79

0.74

*Getting along with people from various cultures, races, backgrounds, etc.

3.52

2.78

0.74

Making and exercising lifelong commitment to learning

3.50

3.00

0.50

Analyzing and drawing conclusions from various types of data

3.49

3.12

0.37

Accessing and using a variety of information

3.46

3.12

0.34

Getting along with people whose attitudes and opinions are different from mine

3.41

2.62

0.79

*Understanding and appreciating cultural and ethnic differences btw people

3.22

2.58

0.64

Appreciating & exercising my rights, responsibilities & priveleges as a citizen

3.14

2.28

0.86

Learning about existing and emerging careers

3.09

2.34

0.75

Understanding the interaction of human beings and the environment

2.97

2.37

0.60

*Understanding international issues (political, economic, etc.)

2.96

2.41

0.55

Understanding and appreciating art, music, literature, etc.

2.70

2.34

0.36

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Goals sorted by gap between importance and impact of UMD

importance

impact

gap

Living my personal and professional life according to my own standard

3.63

2.50

1.13

Developing and using effective leadership skills

3.56

2.61

0.95

Appreciating & exercising my rights, responsibilities & priveleges as a citizen

3.14

2.28

0.86

Getting along with people whose attitudes and opinions are different from mine

3.41

2.62

0.79

Learning about existing and emerging careers

3.09

2.34

0.75

*Getting along with people from various cultures, races, backgrounds, etc.

3.52

2.78

0.74

Developing original ideas and/or products

3.53

2.79

0.74

Recognizing and using effective verbal communication skills

3.77

3.06

0.71

Thinking objectively about beliefs, attitudes, and values

3.56

2.90

0.66

*Understanding and appreciating cultural and ethnic differences btw people

3.22

2.58

0.64

Understanding the interaction of human beings and the environment

2.97

2.37

0.60

*Understanding international issues (political, economic, etc.)

2.96

2.41

0.55

Working cooperatively in groups; working as a team member

3.58

3.06

0.52

Making and exercising lifelong commitment to learning

3.50

3.00

0.50

Defining and solving problems

3.71

3.22

0.49

Recognizing and using effective written communication skills

3.71

3.25

0.46

Analyzing and drawing conclusions from various types of data

3.49

3.12

0.37

Understanding and appreciating art, music, literature, etc.

2.70

2.34

0.36

Accessing and using a variety of information

3.46

3.12

0.34

 

 

 

 

Scale: 4=Major, 3=Moderate, 2=Minor, 1=No importance

 

 

 

 

Appendix E

Student Questionnaire

Student members of the Advisory Group Angel Grubb and Jody Florkowski designed the following questionnaire. It was originally designed to be a verbal survey, but was later given in a written format in order to increase the sample size. It attempts to understand students’ feelings toward their cultural exposure and training at UM-D, as well as their feelings toward the course options that the committee has explored, should faculty decide to adopt such a global/diversity requirement for CASL students.

 

    1. How do you feel about people’s understanding toward people of different cultures, ethnicities, races, religions, genders, nationalities, sexual orientations, etc.?
    2. Do you feel that it is important for us to have a good understanding toward people of different cultures, ethnicities, races, religions, genders, nationalities, sexual orientations, etc.?
    3. Do you feel that your experience at UM-D has heightened your understanding toward people of different groups?
    4. Do you feel that your experience at UM-D has adequately heightened your understanding toward people of different groups?
    5. How well do you feel that your experience at UM-D has heightened your understanding toward people of different groups? (Rate 1 to 10: 1=lowest; 10=highest)
    6. What is your opinion of a required course dealing with diversity/global or tolerance issues if students were allowed to choose the course from a list of courses that dealt with such issues?
    7. What is your opinion of a required course dealing with diversity/global or tolerance issues if this was one course designed specifically to deal with all of these issues, and was required for all future CASL students?
    8. For demographic purposes only, please list your: Academic year ______ Age____ Gender____ Major____________’ With what ethnic or cultural group do you identify yourself?

Students in classes taught by Advisory Group members Thornton (Education), Padmanabhan (Management), Anderson-Levitt (CASL), and Moran (CASL) filled out the questionnaire. Of the 87 respondents, 21 were currently enrolled in a diversity course that is mandatory for most education students, Thornton’s Exploratory Studies 410, Multiculturalism in School and Society.

In reviewing the questionnaires, we found wide-ranging support both for and against the proposed requirement, and for varied reasons. Below is a sample of responses from the questionnaire, focusing primarily on questions four, six and seven on experience at UM-D, on a cafeteria style approach, and on a mandatory course as in the Thornton Proposal.

There seemed to be a general support for the proposal. Although this is not a large nor a particularly representative sample, we note for the sake of discussion that 68% of the students were for a requirement of some sort, 21% were against it, and 11% were neutral. There was a marked concern that UM-D was not providing adequate cultural training to its students. For example, one student wrote that, "especially in a school with a high Muslim population, more discussion could have taken place after 9-11." Another student wrote, "There should be more emphasis on diversity since this college is so diverse." Of the students who recognized a need to address cultural literacy, most supported the addition of a diversity course requirement. "Living in a diverse society requires more attention on those cultures foreign to us. [The proposed course requirement is] a good idea." Another student called it an, "excellent idea," continuing, "I feel it would greatly help the individual and the society." Finally, one student wrote, "Until these things become important enough to be considered required, the issue will continue to be ignored."

It is interesting to note that students who are currently enrolled in or have already taken such a course are overwhelmingly in favor of a requirement (86% of Thornton’s students were for a requirement as opposed to 62 % of the students in other courses). "The masters in Ed. already has a required multiculturalism course, but I feel others could benefit as well." "I think it should be mandatory, because society is diverse, and for a well rounded education, this is necessary," wrote another. Among the students who favored a requirement, there was some preference for a cafeteria style approach (20%) rather than a single mandatory course (8%), although many students expressed no preference (71%), perhaps because of the wording of the questions. Among students currently in Thornton’s mandatory course, however, sentiment was much stronger for a mandatory course (23%) than for a cafeteria-style approach (5%), with 59% expressing no preference.

Some students expressed concern about an additional requirement. "I think it should be offered – not required," writes one. Another writes, "I think it would be an excellent course to offer… [but] should still be optional."

Often, those who opposed it did so because they feared that it could not do the topic justice and serve its purpose effectively. One student wrote, "I think it would backfire if it were to be required; most would not take it seriously." Another expressed concern that if students were required to take the course, they might not benefit from it fully. "I think that it would be a good idea as a course but making it required wouldn’t make much of a difference for people not interested in tolerance."

Finally, there were also many students who opposed the idea of a required course. One student expressed concern stating, "Those who are not interested might resent, rather than embrace, such required courses. I feel that students who are interested will make a point of taking the course, required or not. Don’t require everyone." Another said, "I like the idea, but if it was not required I would not take it, because I feel that I do not have the time or money to do so." Another concern was expressed about the necessity; as one student wrote, "It isn’t needed because you get adequate information on these issues from the current course load."

In conclusion, student opinion varies but of the students that were surveyed there is a strong support for such a course. It is important to recognize that much of the oppositions’ primary concern was in regard to how such a course would be handled.

 

Appendix F

The Study of Graduates’ Transcripts

 

As noted, the Advisory Group commissioned a study from Institutional Research. We wanted to know how many UMD students had taken relevant courses by the time they graduated in the absence of a CASL or campus requirement.

Student Sample

As a sample, we chose the entire population of majors who graduated during one particular academic year, 1999-2000. Recent graduating classes have resembled each other closely, IR advises us, so that this population may be taken as fairly typical.

It is important to note that we counted majors rather than individual students. Counting majors enabled us to ask whether students’ majors affected the likelihood that they would take diversity or global courses. Students with multiple majors were thus counted multiple times, and the counts in our tables should not be misread. Since multiple majors occur in all disciplines pretty evenly, counting majors should not distort our percentage measures. That is, we assume that the percentage of majors who took relevant courses closely approximates the percentage of actual students who took such courses.

For the large number of students who transferred to UMD from other institutions, relevant courses from other institutions were counted only if they transferred in as the exact equivalents of course on our list. The percentage of majors taking at least one course under each model might rise somewhat if transfer courses were scrutinized closely and credited accordingly.

Lists of Courses

To conduct the study, we had to imagine what courses on a student’s transcript might have been relevant. However, what counts as diversity or multiculturalism is a key issue for the whole report. Therefore, rather than producing a single list of courses, we tested three different models:

We asked each department in CASL to help us identify courses that fit each model and to provide syllabi of those courses. When composing our hypothetical lists of relevant courses, we included only those courses for which the course description or a syllabus in hand demonstrated that the course paid substantial attention to the criteria. If we had had a more complete collection of syllabi, we might have developed longer lists and hence the measure of students having taken one or more relevant course might have risen somewhat.

Identifying Relevant Courses

This exercise was useful not only for measuring what students do on their own but also for identifying problems one would have to address if actually establishing a cafeteria-style requirement.

 

Appendix G

Lists of Courses Used in Transcript Study

 

Hypothetical cafeteria-style models used for the purpose of data-gathering

 

Model 1, "Ethnic-cultural" or "Cross-cultural" (31 courses, alphabetic by discipline)

Purpose: To give students an awareness and understanding of the diversity of national and ethnic cultural groups to be found in the U.S. and the world today. Course will give special attention to the distinctive mentalities, cognitive styles, values, and world-views of the group or groups under study.

Criteria: As above. Course may focus on the U.S. or on other societies.

dept

Course number

Course title

Pre-requisites, if any

BS

Anth 202

World Cultures

ANTH 101 recommended.

BS

Anth 370

Indians of North America

ANTH 101 highly rec’d. Must be: Soph., Junior, or Senior.

BS

Anth 371/ AAAS 371

The African Experience in the Americas

None

BS

Anth 372

Introduction to Latin America

None

BS

Anth 373

Anthro. Persp. On Middle East

None

BS

Anth 440

Religion and Culture

ANTH 101 recommended.

BS

Anth 455

Immigrants – USA

ANTH 101

Hu

Arabic 350

Arabic Lit & Culture

None

Hu

Com 430

International Communication

COMP 106 or COMP 220 or COMP 270 or COMP Placement Score 40

Students must be: Graduate, Junior, or Senior.

Hu

Engl 239/ AAAS 239

Intro to Lit: African American

None

Hu

Engl 389/ AAAS 389

Odyssey of Black Men in America

COMP 106 or COMP Placement Score 40 or COMP 220 or COMP 270 and ENGL 230, 231, 232 , 233, 235, 236, 237, 239, 240, or 250

Hu

Engl 469/ AAAS 469

20th Cent. African American Literature

COMP 106 or COMP Placement Score 40 or COMP 220 or COMP 270 and ENGL 230, 231, 232, 233, 235, 236, 237, 239, 240, or 250

Hu

Engl 472

Reading in Multicultural Contexts

Not open to English concentrators.

Hu

French 305

Language of Business

FREN 301

Hu

French 337

France in the 20th Century

FREN 301

Hu

French 339

Francophone Literature and Civilization

FREN 301

Hu

Germ 376

Contemporary German Cultures

GER 301

SS

Hist 108

Colonial Latin America

None

SS

Hist 112

The American Past II

None

SS

Hist 114

Islamic Civilization: 1500 to Present

None

SS

Hist 301

Armenia in World History

None

SS

Hist 316

African American History

None

SS

Hist 323

History of Modern China

None

SS

Hist 328

Women & Islam

None

SS

Hist 345/ AAAS 345

West Africa since 1800

None

SS

Hist 386

Comparative History of Technology

None

BS

Soc 403/ AAAS 403

Minority Groups

SOC 200

BS

Soc 449/ AAAS 449

Black family in contemporary America

SOC 200

Hu

Span 305

Language of Business

SPAN 301

Hu

Span 357

Latin American Civilization and Culture

SPAN 301

SOE

EXPS 410

Multiculturalism in Schools and Society

None

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Model 2, "Equity" or "Tolerance" (39 courses, alphabetic by discipline)

Purpose: To give students an awareness and understanding of intolerance, inequality, and discrimination based on one or more of the following: race, ethnicity, religion, social class, gender, sexual orientation, age, or abilty/disability status.

Criteria: As above. Course may focus on the U.S. or on other societies.

dept

Course number

Course title

Pre-requisites, if any

BS

Anth 371

The African Experience in the Americas

None

BS

Anth 373

Anthro. Persp. On Middle East

None

BS

Anth 406/ WS 406

Culture and Sexuality

ANTH 101 recommended.

BS

Anth 407/ WS 407

Sexual Praxis

WST 275 or SOC 443 or PSYC 405 or ANTH 406 or ANTH 101

BS

Anth 421

Education and Culture

ANTH 101 or SOC 200 recommended.

BS

Anth 455

Immigrants – USA

ANTH 101 recommended. Students must be: Junior, Senior

Hu

Engl 239/ AAAS 239

Intro to Lit: African American

None

Hu

Engl 386/ WST 386

Gender Issues in Literature

ENGL 230, 231, 232, 233, 235, 236, 237, 239, 240, 250

Hu

Engl 389/ AAAS 389

Odyssey of Black Men in America

COMP 106 or COMP Placement Score 40 or COMP 220 or COMP 270 and ENGL 230, 231, 232, 233, 235, 236, 237, 239, 240, 250

Hu

Engl 469

20th Cent. African American Literature

COMP 106 or COMP Placement Score 40 or COMP 220 or COMP 270 and ENGL 230, 231, 232, 233, 235, 236, 237, 239, 240, 250

Hu

French 337

France in the 20th Century

FREN 301

Hu

French 339

Francophone Literature and Civilization

FREN 301

SS

Hist 112

The American Past II

None

SS

Hist 301

Armenia in World History

None

SS

Hist 315

Modern Britain

None

SS

Hist 319

Civil War and Reconstruction

None

SS

Hist 335

20th Century Europe

None

SS

Hist 338/ WST 338

Women & Islam in Mid-East History

None

SS

Hist 359

Era of the World Wars

None

SS

Hist 368/ AAAS 368

Black Experience in America

None

SS

Hist 370/ WST 370

Women in America: Historical Perspective

None

SS

Hist 386

Comparative History of Technology (gender)

None

SS

Hist 387

The Holocaust

None

NS

NS 325/ WST 325

Gender and Science

None

Hu

Phil 233

Critical Thinking

None

SS

PoSc 328

Public Opinion

POL 101

SS

PoSc 371

International Politics

POL 101

SS

PoSc 414

Civil Rights

POL 101; Students must be: Junior, Senior

BS

Psyc 322/ AAAS 322

Psychology of Prejudice

PSYC 171 or PSYC 170

BS

Soc 201

Contemporary Social Problems

None

BS

Soc 304/ Hu 304/ Engl 304

Studies in Detroit Culture

None

BS

Soc 3501

Sociology of Poverty

SOC 200

BS

Soc 403/ AAAS 403

Minority Groups

SOC 200

BS